When to use a Wooden Versus a Steel Garage Door


When it comes to replacing or installing a garage door, there are several options to consider. One of the biggest decisions homeowners are faced with when selecting a new garage door is which material will best fit their needs. Wood and steel garage doors are typically the two popular options and there are pros and cons for each. Garage doors are an investment and you want to be sure you are happy with your choice for years to come.

Wood Garage Door Overview

Wood has long been used to build garage doors, and it remains one of the most popular materials, despite the emergence of alternatives such as metal and fiberglass. Wooden garage doors are very common in high-end homes because the look is elegant and refined.

Wooden garage doors are often custom or semi-custom built, meaning they’re not mass-produced in a factory. They can be designed to perfectly match the look and feel of your home. Opt for real wood, or choose a composite variety that mimics real wood but requires less maintenance.

How Much Do Wood Garage Doors Cost?

Factory-built wooden doors start at about $500 to $600, not including installation, while semi-custom doors cost about $1,500 to $3,000. Custom-built wooden doors start at about $3,000 but can easily reach $10,000 or more.

Wood Garage Doors Pros

  • Attractive – Wooden garage doors are widely considered more elegant and luxurious. They look more expensive (largely because they are more expensive).
  • Customizable – With wooden garage doors, the style possibilities are almost endless. Choose from a wide variety of looks, designs and colors. They’re available in standard and non-standard sizes, too.
  • Won’t dent – Wooden doors won’t dent the way steel doors do. A wooden door is less likely to be damaged if you run into it with the lawn mower or one of the neighborhood kids hits it with a baseball.

Wood Garage Doors Cons

  • More expensive – Wooden garage doors are pricier than steel doors. The materials are more expensive, and the fact that they are usually custom or semi-custom built also drives up the price.
  • Require more maintenance – Wood can warp, rot or chip without proper maintenance. At a minimum, you’ll need to sand and stain or repaint wooden garage doors every few years. Excessive moisture and pests such as termites can also lead to damage.

Metal Garage Door Overview

There are several types of metal garage doors, including steel, aluminum and iron. Steel garage doors are by far the most common — this is what most people are talking about when they refer to metal doors.

Steel doors are usually factory-built, meaning they come preassembled. Because of this, the color, design and size options are limited. You won’t find steel garage doors in non-standard sizes.

How Much Do Metal Garage Doors Cost?

Steel garage doors usually sell for anywhere from $400 to $1,200, not including installation. Very basic doors with no windows fall on the low end of that range, while fancier varieties with windows and decorative features fall on the high end. The highest-quality steel doors go for as much as $1,500.

Metal Garage Doors Pros

  • Affordable – Steel garage doors are far less expensive than wooden doors. They’re a great option if you’re on a tight budget.
  • Easier to maintain – You’ll never have to sand, stain or paint metal garage doors. Simply power wash them from time to time to keep them clean.
  • Lighter – Steel garage doors are much lighter in weight than wood doors. They’re easier to install, and they’re easier to open if you don’t have an automatic garage door opener or if the automatic opener breaks.

Metal Garage Doors Cons

  • Prone to rust – Steel garage doors are likely to rust over time. If you live in an extremely moist or coastal climate, they’re probably not the best choice.
  • Prone to dents – Steel garage doors are much more susceptible to dents and dings.
  • Fewer design options – Because steel doors are factory built, the size, design and color options or limited. You won’t be able to customize the garage door to match the style of your home.

Having a wooden door will dramatically improve the curb appeal of your home. A wood garage door can increase the property value of your home as well.  On the other hand, since wood garage doors tend to be on the higher end of the price range, there are now many steel doors that mimic the look of a wooden door that you could also consider if budget is a concern for you.

From an investment standpoint you really can’t beat steel, but when it comes to overall looks, you have to go with wood while you can fabricate the look of wood with faux wood or Steel Clopay carriage style doors, a metal door isn’t going to look as elegant and refined as its wooden counterpart. Steel may have the advantage in maintenance, but you can’t beat wood when it comes to style. But finally choice is yours!

To be safe and lower risks, it is best to hire a professional garage door specialist.  The specialist can determine and address the problems of your garage door and propose a feasible solution.  Feel free to contact us any time for help.  Call Yuval at (215) 805-9209 or visit SecureGarages.com – don’t forget our Awesome Amazon Local Deal!  Garage adjustment, reconditioning + safety inspection. and for another $34 we will replace up to 8 rollers!  Mention Code: Secure4Sure10 to get another 10% off your order!

garage coupon

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *